When it comes to prospects, there is a huge unknown element, but the Philadelphia Phillies weighed the risk and reward of giving up Marlon Byrd and came away with a future star in pitcher Ben Lively.
Look at it this way: Byrd was 38 and, although he hit .264 with 25 home runs, the risk of trading him to the Cincinnati Reds was not that high. As the Phillies have found with their other aging stars in the past few years, with age comes a drop in production. There was no guarantee that Byrd would match that 25/85/.264 line again and it’s even more likely that he will fall off those numbers rather dramatically.
With Lively, though, there is a significant upside. Lively’s ceiling is a No. 1 or No. 2 starter on a contending team and that’s a pretty nice looking roof. The 2013 fourth-round pick out of the University of Central Florida has the advantage most of the other pitchers selected high do not — high-level college experience. Those are the kinds of guys who rise quickly through the system and end up on major-league rosters fast.
That had to help him rise up the charts of highly-rated prospects in the Reds’ system, ranked No. 12 by Baseball America at the end of the 2014 season and that’s odd because the Reds rated him their No. 1 prospect, giving him their Minor League Player of the Year award. The numbers support the pick because he started in Class-A Bakersfield (Calif.) with a 2.28 ERA in 79 innings. After a promotion to Class-AA Pensacola (Fla.), he had a 3.88 ERA with 9.5 strikeouts per nine innings — as good an indication of his stuff as any stat line. He was 13-7 with a 3.04 ERA between those two teams.
If Lively can duplicate those numbers in Triple-A this season with the Phillies, he should not have to wait long for a call-up to the big leagues. Since Lively figures to stay long-term and Byrd was a rental, the Phillies came out ahead in this deal.
Mike Gibson is a Phillies writer for www.RantSports.com. Follow him on Twitter @papreps , “Like” him on Facebook or add him to your network on Google.
Madison Bumgarner can do no wrong. The latest installment in the legend of the Giants Wold Series hero, a picture of him holding an ax standing beside an ox. Seriously. Read More
Pitchers and catchers have barely reported to Spring Training, yet rumblings out of Seattle Mariners' camp is that James Paxton already hurt himself. Read More
The Cleveland Indians are flying under the radar coming into the 2015 season. Here are their five most intense position battles. Read More
Are the New York Yankees really committed to their own plan to rebuild the farm system and return to greatness? Read More
The Atlanta Braves will have a host of rookie invites to spring training camp this year. Take a look at five prospects to keep an eye on. Read More
Despite a deal with Everth Cabrera that is reportedly in the works, the best solution to the Baltimore Orioles' leadoff problem will likely be found in the outfield. Read More
Will the addition of the most coveted free agent picture this offseason shift the balance of power in MLB to the NL East? Read More
Several exciting young players in the Kansas City Royals system hope to turn heads with their play in the 2015 Cactus League. Here are five Royals rookies to look out for this spring. Read More
2015 Spring Training is getting underway this week. Check out five breakout candidates for the Atlanta Braves. Read More
The Boston Red Sox signing elite prospect Yoan Moncada allows the team to part with other prospects to trade for Cole Hamels. Read More
The New York Yankees needed Yoan Moncada but allowing him to sign with the Boston Red Sox turns whole offseason into a failure. Read More
Atlanta Braves center fielder B.J. Upton will go by his birth name Melvin Jr. in 2015. Braves fans will be hoping other things change for him as well. Read More