Barring an unforeseen acquisition, the San Francisco Giants will enter the 2015 season with four question marks clouding their starting rotation, including two-time Cy Young Award winner Tim Lincecum. Although “The Freak” has been dominant in stretches (see his 30.1 shutout innings streak from last season), the Giants’ former ace is shades of his former self, in large part due to a severe decrease in velocity.
The Giants need Lincecum to become a permanent factor if they’re going to contend for the NL West crown in 2015. Even though Lincecum no longer pounds the zone with two-seam fastballs exceeding 95 mph, he’s capable of being an effective pitcher when able to locate that pitch. Most of Lincecum’s struggles have been chalked up to a sharp decline in pitch speed, but command has dogged the 30-year-old veteran for big chunks of the past three seasons.
It’s possible — and widely talked about on the social media-sphere — that Lincecum is best suited for a bullpen role in the late innings. The Giants are hesitant to prematurely make that switch, and rightfully so. Even though Lincecum has been willingly adaptable over recent postseason runs, it’s unknown if he has serious interest in becoming a permanent relief pitcher. The $18 million price tag attached to his name also understandably makes the Giants more apt to trying anything they can to remake “The Freak” into a productive starter.
Steamer projections indicate that Lincecum will — at some point — adopt a relief role in 2015. Lincecum posted his first winning record since 2010 last season (12-9), but he also recorded an inefficient 4.74 ERA. According to Steamer projections, Lincecum will start 25 games in the upcoming season before giving way to a bullpen role. He’s projected to register a 9-10 record with a 4.01 ERA and 147 strikeouts over 169.0 innings in 50 appearances.
If those metrics prove accurate, Lincecum would be significantly more effective out of the bullpen than as a starter. Throughout his career, Lincecum has become less dependent on the fastball. He threw the two-seamer on just 31.2 percent of his pitches last year while averaging a modest 89.6 mph, according to FanGraphs. His complementary pitches have become more effective as he’s grown as a pitcher, as indicated by his reliance on the slider, which he threw on 26.1 percent of his pitches in 2014.
The consistent year-to-year dip in Lincecum’s velocity could be mitigated by a relief role. Giants setup man Sergio Romo has excelled throughout his career without ever consistently exceeding 90 mph on the radar gun. His no-dot slider enables him to use the fastball as a complement when effective. For Lincecum, the inverse is reality. His secondary pitches are typically only effective when he’s able to spot the fastball on the corners.
The Giants ultimately have a difficult decision to make regarding the future of Lincecum, who could be entering his final season in San Francisco. His epic performance out of the bullpen in the 2012 postseason showed that he’s capable of being a dominant reliever. It may be time to make that switch permanent.
John Shea is an MLB writer for www.RantSports.com. Follow him on Twitter @real_johnshea. Like him on Facebook or add him to your network on Google.
This winter has been crazy for MLB transactions. Here is a look at 10 players who could still be traded. Read More
Dontrelle Willis hasn't pitched since 2011, but here is why his return with the Milwaukee Brewers will be special. Read More
The San Diego Padres have greatly improved their offense this offseason, but they must bolster their 25-man roster if they're going to legitimately contend in 2015. Read More
These MLB players have a lot to offer in terms of money, fame and good looks. A woman who can get any of these athletes to say "I do" will be surely living the lifestyle of the rich and famous. Read More
It seems like nobody really knows where he's going, but James Shields is making plenty of news by not yet being signed. Read More
Ruben Amaro’s recent statements about Ryan Howard being productive again suggest the Phillies have a larger issue to deal with in the way their GM sees things. Read More
Josh Harrison was a huge surprise for the Pittsburgh Pirates last season, but he won't be able to put up similar numbers in 2015. Read More
The New York Mets didn't play the Washington Nationals well at all in 2014. They must improve in that department if they really want to be competitive. Read More
In what has to be the most riduclous thing to happen in the offseason, Alex Rodriguez has been getting back into baseball shape by training with Barry Bonds. Read More
The Washington Nationals are gearing up for a run at the World Series. To do so, they may need to trade former top pick Stephen Strasburg. Read More
The Oakland Athletics are continued to compete by developing young players and trading some prospects for veterans. They will be a force to reckon with for years with the help of these 10 prospects. Read More
The New York Yankees could turn their whole offseason into a huge win by signing Yoan Moncada. Read More