Player A- 12 sacks, 51 total tackles, 60 total quarterback pressures (including sacks; per Pro Football Focus). Seventh-best 4-3 defensive end in the league, according to Pro Football Focus.
Player B- 10.5 sacks , 45 total tackles, 35 quarterback pressures; 13 tackles for loss and five forced fumbles. No. 1 4-3 defensive end in the league in 2013 (Pro Football Focus).
Both of these players are clearly Pro Bowl-level defensive ends this year, but I would argue Player A, Minnesota Vikings defensive end Everson Griffen is a bit more worthy of a Pro Bowl nod than Player B, St. Louis Rams defensive end Robert Quinn. Yet Quinn was voted to the original roster on Tuesday, while Griffen had to settle for being named an alternate. With plenty of players likely to bow out due to lingering injuries or their team making it to the Super Bowl, Griffen may still make the trip to Glendale, Arizona on Jan. 25. But he should have been on the initial Pro Bowl roster, and there’s no doubt in my mind about that.
Of the four 4-3 defensive ends currently on the Pro Bowl roster, three (Demarcus Ware-10, Quinn-10.5, and Cameron Wake-11.5) have fewer sacks than Griffen. Going a little deeper, again via Pro Football Focus, only Wake (61) has been credited with more total quarterback pressures than Griffen among the quartet of 4-3 defensive ends that were voted to the Pro Bowl.
Advanced Football Analytics.com further backs up Griffen’s breakout 2014 season, ranking him third in Win Probability Added among all defensive ends, regardless of defensive scheme. The top two? Jason Pierre-Paul, who himself qualifies as a Pro Bowl snub with 10.5 sacks and 72 total tackles so far this season, and J.J Watt.
Voting for All-Star games in any sport is largely skewed by a player’s popularity and reputation, and the Pro Bowl is no different. Actual production on the field takes a back seat at times, and team success also plays a role in who gets the recognition they deserve. This is Griffen’s first season as a starter, and the Vikings’ 6-9 record with one game to go surely worked against him compared to his peers.
I expect Griffen’s performance this season to help set the stage for him to make multiple trips to the Pro Bowl, as he becomes more of a household name around the league and the Vikings start winning more games. Even if he doesn’t wind up replacing someone on the Pro Bowl roster this time around, Griffen is well on his way to becoming one of the NFL’s best defensive ends for many years to come.
Brad Berreman is a Columnist at Rant Sports.com. Connect with him on Twitter or Google +.
This is the year that Tony Romo finally exorcises his playoff demons and proves to all of his doubters that he can deliver in the big games. Read More
With two of the first 19 picks in the 2015 NFL Draft, the Browns are in great position to improve on a 7-9 season. Here's a look at the direction the team may take. Read More
With tensions high in the Eagles' front office, a shocking decision might just become more realistic. Read More
If the Dallas Cowboys are to walk away from Sunday's matchup vs. the Detroit Lions with a win, their offensive line must rise to the occasion. Read More
The New England Patriots are in "Super Bowl or bust" mode heading into the playoffs. When the season ends, there will be several question marks. Here are the five biggest rumors heading into 2015. Read More
The Philadelphia Eagles looked good in the first half of the season. But things fell apart and the Eagles missed the playoffs. Here are the five things the team must improve on for 2015. Read More
Now that we know the College Football Playoff championship matchup, it's time to evaluate the rosters. Here's a look at the 15 players who could be selected in the 2015 NFL Draft. Read More
The Patriots' postseason doesn't start for another week, giving them time to fix some pressing issues. Here are the five biggest questions for Patriots heading into the playoffs. Read More
The Eagles are choosing the wrong side with their latest move in the front office. Read More
With some needs and contracts becoming an issue over the offseason, the Green Bay Packers need to have a solid 2015 NFL Draft. Read More
Find out which key members of the 2014 Cleveland Browns may be playing elsewhere in 2015. Read More
These five veterans may not return for the New York Giants in 2015. Read More