Morgan Rielly Did Not Deserve Healthy Scratch by Toronto Maple Leafs
Randy Carlyle is rightfully being questioned for his decision to make Morgan Rielly a healthy scratch in the Toronto Maple Leafs‘ 4-3 shootout loss to the Colorado Avalanche.
Rielly has been Toronto’s best defensemen through the first month of the season and hasn’t shown any signs of suffering from a sophomore slump. Unfortunately, like most NHL players, Rielly failed to play 82 perfect games this season, and had an awful outing in a 3-2 loss against the Arizona Coyotes.
The highlight of Rielly’s bad night was when Toronto had finally found the scoreboard, cutting Arizona’s lead to 3-1. The Maple Leafs possessed all the momentum after scoring their first goal and had all the pressure in the Coyote’s zone. Rielly then turned the puck over and lost track of his man before taking a penalty in an attempt to limit a two-on-one opportunity for Arizona. The Maple Leafs managed to kill off the penalty, but had lost all the momentum the team had built prior to Rielly’s penalty.
Sitting a young defender in his second season after a tough night would normally be fine on any other team in the league. But in Rielly’s case, the sophomore didn’t deserve to be scratched against Colorado because he’d done enough to earn a pass on one bad performance. It’s not like this was a string of three or four bad games by Rielly, in which case sitting him would have been more justified.
Jake Gardiner had a pathetic turnover against the Coyotes where he appeared to be scared of getting hit, yet he played against the Avalanche before being injured. Stephane Robidas hasn’t even come close to outplaying Rielly once this season, yet he played against Colorado. Stuart Percy, who has been a pleasant surprise this season, also played against the Avalanche despite not deserving to be in the lineup over Rielly.
Carlyle is clearly attempting to send a message to Rielly, as the coach likely understands he needs the young defender to be playing at a high-level every night if the Maple Leafs stand any shot of making the playoffs. There’s no question Rielly contains the type of potential where he could be the direct key to Toronto making or missing the postseason, and this could simply be an attempt by Carlyle to motivate him.
However, given how strong Rielly has been through the first month of the season, it begs the question as to whether or not it was fair of Carlyle to scratch him. He had certainly done enough to deserve the opportunity of bouncing back from the Arizona game without having to sit in the press box, and it likely would have given the player more confidence that his coach believed in him.
This could be the type of move that backfires on Carlyle as Rielly could be looking over his shoulder after every mistake, or even playing scared and worried about sitting again. Gardiner has certainly endured a crisis of confidence courtesy of Carlyle, and if the coach begins to mentally effect Rielly as well, the Maple Leafs could see their two potential-filled puck-moving defensemen begin to regress.
Maple Leafs Should Consider Trading James Reimer
It's apparent that the Toronto Maple Leafs have committed to Jonathan Bernier as their No. 1 goaltender. It is time to move on from James Reimer and trade him. Read More
Maple Leafs Shouldn't Trade For Mike Richards
Find out why the Toronto Maple Leafs shouldn't pursue a trade for Mike Richards. Read More
Red Wings Should Shop Jonas Gustavsson
Detroit Red Wings' backup goaltender Jonas Gustavsson should be in play for a trade, as the return to form of Jimmy Howard and the emergence of Petr Mrazek makes him expendable. Read More
Vigneault Must Let The Kids Play For Rangers
The New York Rangers are a relatively old team, but they have some young talent. Alain Vigneault needs to let his kids play. Read More
Phil Kessel Shouldn't Have to Talk to the Media
Read why it's pointless for the media to criticize Phil Kessel for not talking to reporters after games. Read More
5 Takeaways From Kings' Early-Season Play
Fresh off their second title in three years, the Los Angeles Kings have hit a speed bump on the road to a dynasty. Here are five things we've learned from their early-season play. Read More
5 Takeaways From Bruins' Early-Season Play
It's been an up-and-down season for the Boston Bruins. They lost Zdeno Chara, they keep losing to their longtime rivals and they've only beaten one above .500 team. But hey, it's a long season, right? Read More
Islanders Should Consider Trading Anders Lee
Anders Lee has been lost in the shuffle with the New York Islanders and could be on his way out of town soon. Read More
NHL Power Rankings For Week 6
This is where all 30 NHL teams stand through six weeks of the rigorous 2014-15 season. Read More
5 Takeaways From Strong Habs Win Against Red Wings
The Montreal Canadiens have now won six in a row, their longest winning streak since 2010. In this strong game, what are the takeaways? Read More
5 Takeaways From Red Wings' Early-Season Play
They've only played 16 games this season, but the Detroit Red Wings look poised to continue their long tradition of success. Here are five takeaways from the Detroit Red Wings' early-season play. Read More
Predators Should Trade Volchenkov
Anton Volchenkov was signed by the Nashville Predators for leadership, but his decreased production and recent suspension make him expendable. Read More